Fed Chairman Emphasizes Strong Economy and Labor Market, Cautions Unsustainable Debt and Trade Developments Pose Risks
The labor market is incredibly strong and the economic outlook favorable, yet risks remain. That was Federal Reserve Chairman Jerome Powell’s message to Congress on Nov. 13.
Powell highlighted many positive features of the economic outlook, including:
- The economy is in its 11th year of expansion and the “baseline outlook remains favorable.”
- Unemployment of 3.6 percent is “near a half-century low.”
- Income gains are widespread and largest among lower-wage workers. “People who live and work in low- and middle-income communities tell us that many who have struggled to find work are now getting opportunities to add new and better chapters to their lives.”
- Labor force participation is up as “Ample job opportunities appear to have encouraged many people to join the workforce and others to remain in it.”
- Household consumption continues to rise thanks to “a healthy job market, rising incomes, and favorable levels of consumer confidence.”
- and middle-income workers.
Important risks remain, though:
- “The federal budget is on an unsustainable path, with high and rising debt” which could limit the government’s ability to provide fiscal supports in a downturn. Moreover, “high and rising federal debt can, in the longer term, restrain private investment and, thereby, reduce productivity and overall economic growth.”
- Trade restrictions are hurting the economy. In particular, business investment “is being restrained by sluggish growth abroad and trade developments,” and trade developments also have “weighed on exports and manufacturing this year.”
- At 1.7% for the core personal consumption expenditure, inflation is slightly below the Fed’s 2% goal. “Persistent below-target inflation could lead to an unwelcome downward slide in longer-term inflation expectations.”
Powell’s caution about unsustainable and rising debt is noteworthy. Already, the $23 trillion national debt amounts to $178,300 per household in the U.S. Add on Social Security’s $13.9 trillion in unfunded obligations over the next 75 years and Medicare’s $42.3 trillion, and total debt plus unfunded obligations rises to $614,000 per household. With a median household income of just over $63,000, that’s clearly unsustainable.
And it’s not just the already-high debt, it’s the risk that such high debt will cause a spike in interest rates, requiring drastic spending cuts at the same time as massive tax increases. According to the Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget, just a 1% increase in interest rates would raise interest costs by $1.9 trillion over the next 10 years. On a per-household basis, that’s an extra $147,300 over 10 years.
But 1% interest rate increases are mild compared to recent historical fiscal crises. In Greece, interest rates rose by about 8% from 2010 to 2011, and briefly surpassed 35% in 2012. In Puerto Rico, rates spiked as much as 2.5% in a single month. When governments can’t borrow at reasonable rates, they face extremely limited choices.
If U.S. policymakers continue to spend without restraint and put off confronting out-of-control entitlement program growth, modest reforms no longer will be possible. Austerity will be the only option.
Take Greece, for example. Its forced austerity measures of spending cuts and tax increases amounted to 40% of gross domestic product and caused the economy to shrink by 25% and the unemployment rate to rise to 27%. That austerity “saddled Greece with suffocatingly high taxes, deterring business activity and contributing to heavy emigration, especially of young and educated people,” according to a recent Wall Street Journal article.
That’s why the U.S.’s unsustainable debt is arguably one of America’s greatest threats.
Failure to address this now could mean that today’s generation of children could be the first to reverse America’s trend of upward economic movement and instead end up worse-off than their parents.
But that doesn’t have to be the case.
Solving our fiscal crisis is not easy, but it is possible and the Heritage Foundation has a plan that would balance the budget within 10 years, let workers keep more of their hard-earned dollars, and give individuals more control over their future. As Powell pointed out, putting the U.S. budget on a “sustainable path” would boost the growth and “vigor” of the U.S. economy and give policymakers the tools to provide stability in future downturns.